A Publication of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Oakland
Catholic Voice Online Edition
Front Page In this Issue Around the Diocese Forum News in Brief Calendar Commentary
Mission Statement
Contact Us
Publication Dates
Back Issues

Roman Catholic Diocese of Oakland

Movie Reviews

Mass Times

Catholic Voice
Letters from
our readers

Pope Francis' reflections: Care affectionately for elderly

Whose life is it anyway: thoughts on assisted suicide

Beautiful metaphor in nature gives us insight into Church'

Bishop hopes 'fictional memoir' appeals to Catholics, non-Catholics

Califorina bishops urge action


placeholder March 23, 2015   •   VOL. 53, NO. 6   •   Oakland, CA
Letters from Readers
Bishop hopes 'fictional memoir' appeals to Catholics, non-Catholics

By Mark Pattison
Catholic News Service

WASHINGTON "I'm no author," averred retired Bishop Francis A. Quinn. Well, he is now. Bishop Quinn, at age 93, has become a first-time author, telling his life story in what he termed a "fictional memoir," chronicling the lives of three priests from their days in a high school seminary in "Behind Closed Doors: Conflicts in Today's Church."

Behind Closed Doors: Conflicts in Today's Church By retired Bishop Francis A. Quinn
Anyone interested in buying it online shouldn't look for "Bishop" in the author's name. Instead, he used Francis Anthony Quinn.

In a telephone interview with Catholic News Service from the assisted-living facility in Sacramento where he lives, Bishop Quinn said, laughing, "I figured it ('bishop') would draw some people but scare others off; they think it's going to be a religious book. And it could scare off non-Catholics, people of other faiths, thinking this was just going to be a Catholic book."

Bishop Quinn said he wrote the book over a six-year period after he retired as Sacramento's bishop in 1993 and did mission work among American Indians in Arizona. "I had a lot of time on my hands," he said. He spent more than a dozen years traveling from reservation to reservation in a recreational vehicle given to him by priests of the Sacramento Diocese.

In 2007, he returned to his native California. As bishop, he was known for his one-on-one ministry with the poor in Sacramento, sharing words and perhaps some money with the homeless, serving free meals or washing dishes at a soup kitchen, and visiting migrant labor camps in the summer.

The book got an early endorsement from retired Archbishop John R. Quinn of San Francisco; Bishop Quinn was a San Francisco auxiliary before being named to Sacramento. Following the archbishop's endorsement, "I was going to put under it in parentheses, 'Not a relative,'" Bishop Quinn said.

"There being two bishops in San Francisco at the same time named Quinn was just a Quinn-cidence. What a pun. I thought it would be too foolish to put it in there." The three main characters in the book are David Carmichael, wanting to be well-liked but quiet and unsure of himself; Ladd Franklin, a restless, questioning sort who eschews parish ministry for Catholic Relief Services; and Tyler Stone, who is accused of sexual misconduct near the end of his priestly ministry.

Bishop Quinn said there's "50 or 60 percent" of himself in the character of Carmichael the only one who, like him, is ordained a bishop about 50 percent in the Franklin character, as Bishop Quinn himself served many years overseas with CRS, but only about 10 percent in the character of Stone, putting Stone's upbringing in Tucson, Arizona, on a parallel with his own.

The bishop hastened to say he had never, unlike Stone's character, been accused of any sexual misconduct during his priestly ministry. The dramatic tension in "Behind Closed Doors" comes courtesy of the Caprice family.

There's Msgr. Gordon Caprice, the super-smart and super-skilled seminarian who becomes a chancery big shot; his sister, Willow, who has an unrequited love for Ladd Franklin and becomes a career Foreign Service officer ("the relationship with Willow is strictly fictional," he said); and their father, George, head of a group called Guardians of Doctrine GOD for short ready to pounce upon any pastoral, theological or liturgical abuse, real or imagined, and protest it to the highest levels necessary.

The book's chronology begins in the years before World War II, although not much time is spent on the war because, at Bishop Quinn's fictional seminary, students weren't allowed to listen to the radio. It ends decades later, with the appointment of a new archbishop for the make-believe Archdiocese of San Tomas.

While written as fiction, the characters are "based on reality, people that I've known, or priests and bishops that I've known," Bishop Quinn told CNS.

"Those things like the visit to Russia and the visit to the Philippines, being awakened in the middle of the night with a gun at my head and a flashlight in my eyes, that really happened, but the chase through Argentina and Brazil with someone trying to recapture that tape, that's fiction. I was down in those countries but not for any purpose other than helping out at CRS."

Apart from the fictionalized elements of "Behind Closed Doors," "there are homilies in there that I wanted to intersperse in the story, hoping that people who read it as a novel would get some information about the church," Bishop Quinn said. "It probably slows up the narrative, but they (readers) can skip over that and follow the novel part."

Copyright © 2015 The Catholic Voice, All Rights Reserved. Site design by Sarah Kalmon-Bauer.