A Publication of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Oakland
Catholic Voice Online Edition
Front Page In this Issue Around the Diocese Forum News in Brief Calendar Commentary
Mission Statement
Contact Us
Publication Dates
Back Issues

Roman Catholic Diocese of Oakland

Movie Reviews

Mass Times

Catholic Voice
 August 6, 2012   •   VOL. 50, NO. 13   •   Oakland, CA
Other front page stories
Most Rev. Cordileone
named archbishop of SF

Oakland's St. Bernard Parish
celebrating its 100th birthday

Andrew Moore led a life
dedicated to life

50th anniversary symposium
'This is more than a remembrance'
Bishop Emeritus John S. Cummins

For Bishop Emeritus John S. Cummins, the jubilee of the Diocese of Oakland is an opportunity to consider its roots. At a symposium he will moderate on Sept. 9, four speakers will discuss Vatican II documents and the role they play in the church today.

"There's so much antagonism about the Vatican Council," he said. "We've got to interpret this correctly."

For Bishop Cummins, who spoke with Staff Writer Michele Jurich, the symposium is "more than a remembrance" but rather an exploration of the vibrancy of the church today.

On why we celebrate anniversaries

John XXIII said anniversaries aren't just opportunities, but obligations.

Life gets routine, daily, you have to go after the memories, the things you treasure.

Michael Collins, a Christian Brother from Minneapolis, came to study at USF. He had me out to Saint Mary's High for the 117th anniversary. I said, What's this about?

"Unless you celebrate," he said, "you'll lose your memory."

Vatican II and the upcoming Year of Faith

What came out is two things that should be read: documents of the Second Vatican Council — that's a long time since I've heard Rome telling people to read the documents, especially the big four: church, church and the world, liturgy and scripture — and the Catechism of the Church.

Vatican II documents are readable. You don't have to be highly educated. But you don't just sit down and read the Catechism. That's a reference book.

Oakland diocese and Vatican II

Things are embedded in this diocese and in the church. People are worried about going backward. There's no way we are going to go backward.

How he responds to 'you had a hard job'
I don't remember a morning I didn't want to go to work.

Timing is everything

Vatican II has formed this diocese and formed this church. For us, it was because of timing. The diocese was formed in April 1962 and the bishop went to the Council in October 1962.

Symposium topics, speakers

• Implementation of "The Dogmatic Constitution on the Church," "Lumen Gentium," in the Diocese of Oakland, Rev. Joseph Chinnici, OFM, president, Franciscan School of Theology.

• Implementation of the document "The Church in the Modern World," "Gaudium et Spes," in the Diocese of Oakland, Rev. John A. Coleman, SJ, professor emeritus, Jesuit School of Theology.

• Influence of Vatican II on the life and faith practices of laity and religious in the Diocese of Oakland, Mary Ann Mattos, vice principal for Curriculum Development and Academic Services, De La Salle High School, and Sister Rose Marie Hennessy, OP, prioress general emerita of the Dominican Sisters of Mission San Jose.

Moderator: Most Rev. John S. Cummins, bishop emeritus, Diocese of Oakland
Roots of change

My classmates disagree with me on this. The seminary had fired us up for change. Scripture studies were really changing. The role of laity had changed. Religious liberty.

Then there had been big changes in liturgy. The Easter Vigil had been restored, to the evening instead of the one at 7:30 a.m. with 10 people. The fasting from midnight got dropped.

In '58-'59, when John XXIII announced the Council, all these things we had been reading about had real relevance, because this was going to be at the Council.

Bishop Floyd L. Begin

Floyd Begin was absolutely unequivocal was about doing whatever came out of the Council. You couldn't overdo it. He hated Communion in the hand, he went to his grave happy that hadn't gone through. Bishop Begin used to say he did not miss one minute of the Vatican Council. (Historian) Jeff Burns quotes this. A priest went in to see Bishop Begin and quoted a Vatican II document. The bishop said to him, "Don't quote that to me. I wrote those documents."

Changes in parish life

Every parish must have a parish council. We also had a lot of collaboration with the bishop. Most pastors welcomed and were accepting. When I came, half had parish councils.

RCIA came out of the Council. This is quite a change. At Mills College I was chaplain. We had two or three converts every year. I'd have to sit there and instruct them. There was no idea of tying them into a community.

People of God

People of God is embedded. (Rev.) Joe Chinnici has a book on the acceptance of the Vatican Council in America. You have the word equality — baptism — and also the responsibility for the life and health of the church that goes with baptism. There's opportunity and initiative. It was up to the diocese to provide opportunity. These consultative bodies were so important to that. These parish councils, which didn't move too fast, but when the new canon law came out, finance councils were required. You didn't have an option on that.

I couldn't get over the resistance to parish councils. RCIA moved across the diocese. But I asked one priest about his parish council. "The last time I looked, I was fine," he said.

The laity finds its voice

The invitation from the Council was for people to speak their mind to authority. You do it with love and respect. But that really changes things. We grew up under: The laity participate and the apostolate is the hierarchy.

Initiatives launched

OCO, our sisters, CISCO, St., Mary's Center, Next Step Learning Center, GRIPP, Birthright, , A Friendly Place, Providence House, FACE. All these things took place with initiative.

People of God

We are the church. That is a very common expression. It usually means, "Don't tell us what to do." It really is a confrontational. It's part of the engagement. It's wonderful.

Style of authority

Walter Burgharat said in 1979: The old style of authority and obedience just is not adequate when you're talking about the dignity of the human person and everybody responsible for the church and the Holy Spirit dealing with everybody.


When people know they have stake in this thing. Under that comes holiness of life. Spiritual directors … that's a very common thing for the laity now. Sacrament of penance is built for that. You sit down and talk, you don't just give a laundry list of faults.

Changes in the sacraments

The way we do Confirmation now, with the involvement of the parish, is so different. Anointing of the sick used to be a terror sacrament. Now it's just lovely.

We can talk now about liturgical spirituality. The old way, you had devotional spirituality.
Daily preaching. The cycles of the Scripture. The old days, we'd have St. Matthew on almost every Sunday.


That idea of the world as a sacred place. We never talked about the lay vocation before. We do now.

Mass in the vernacular

Nobody at the Vatican Council thought we'd have three vernaculars in one parish.


The cycles, the opening of scripture. How scripture became basis of prayer, theology. People got interest in scriptural studies. Many scripture people Raymond Brown, Sandra Schneiders, Javk Boyle, Barbara Green.

We're now biblical people and that was not true before the Council.

Change comes to the church

When I came in 1977, every department was run by a priest. That was getting pretty well past the Council years. We reorganized three times. We had a guy in who said,

"You're like the Mississippi River, you're three miles wide and only a foot deep." His point was everybody was reporting to you and you can't do that.

Monday morning, would be show and tell, whatever you're doing. There was one day when there were more laity than priests. And the next day there were more women than men. Everybody noticed, and nobody said anything. That was something.

A pastoral council for the diocese

Pastoral council — priests, laity, religious — that's your primary consultative body. (Rev.) Brian Joyce led this. Two weekends at Holy Names, 400 people. I felt, "This is church." They came up for five directives for the next decade: lay development, young people, social justice — you could not have believed that would have come up third, if you were running around the diocese, that wasn't coming up, there were the Bill O'Donnells … The fourth was education. The inner-city schools were concerns, religious education was too. Fifth was evangelization. Nobody would have predicted that. That set us on a pattern. I always called that the Big Five.


In September 1962, before he went to the Vatican Council, Bishop Begin invited 150 Protestant ministers and their wives to the Claremont Hotel for dinner. Robert McAfee Brown was the featured speaker. He said Boston had no "Cushing Concourse." And there was no "Cardinal Cooke Parkway" in New York. But in so many places in Alameda and Contra Costa counties there was the sign, "Begin Freeway."

Floyd gets up. He never prepared anything, which drove us crazy, He said, "I don't know whey I called you here, but I love you." That was quoted in the 1990s.

He sent me back in 1963 to the National Conference on Religion and Race in Chicago. The host was Albert Meyer, the cardinal, and the first speaker was Abraham Heschel, the rabbi, and the final speaker was Martin Luther King. We all sang, "We Shall Overcome." The instructions were you go home and start a local committee.

Next issue: Vatican Council reconvenes in 1963 — and this time, Bishop Begin takes along his young chancellor, John Cummins.

Next Front Page Article

back to topup arrow


Copyright © 2011 The Catholic Voice, All Rights Reserved. Site design by Sarah Kalmon-Bauer.